An Eye for an Eye — Inside the Classic
Edition facts
The catalog record for An Eye for an Eye — Inside the Classic provides practical reading context through 78,715 words, 5 hr 43 min estimated reading time, and 9 detected text sections.
The text analysis averages about 17.6 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.
Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “London (England) -- Fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.
Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.
How this score is calculated
- Description quality20 pts
- Title & short description10 pts
- Source metadata20 pts
- Text length15 pts
- Chapters / structure15 pts
- EPUB file integrity20 pts
Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.
Read the Text
Cleugh was one of the queer figures in journalistic London. Essentially of the Bohemian type, easy-going and possessed of a quaint, dry humour, many were the stories told in Fleet Street of his utter disregard for the _convenances_. Shrewd, witty, clever, well-educated, he was no respecter of persons. If he went forth to make an inquiry for his journal, he hesitated at nothing. With the constant companionship of an extremely foul briar pipe, it was his habit to "interview" people and obtain "latest details" of the day's sensation without removing it from his lips, and it was well-known down at the Press Club, that dingy but interesting institution in Wine Office Court, that on one field-day at Aldershot he had actually chatted with the Commander-in-Chief, pipe in mouth, and afterwards put the conversation "on the wire" in the form of an interview. When having nothing to do he would clean that pipe for recreation, and such operation usually caused a rapid exit from the vicinity. Known to all in Fleet Street as "the Mystery Man," he was clever-looking and dignified, and could snuff out an uncommunicative secretary, or a pompous policeman, with his marvellous control of expressions, sarcastic without being abusive. He was undoubtedly "a smart man"--and to be smart in journalism nowadays requires a good deal more than ordinary intelligence. An ex-Jesus man, he had been a True Blue, been ploughed for the Army, studied medicine, and travelled pretty widely, until having been a brilliant failure he had drifted into journalism, like so many other men have drifted, commencing as an outside contributor, or "liner," and eventually, by dint of the swiftness and marvellous tact and ability with which he got at the bottom of the inquiries he made, he joined the regular staff of a popular evening sheet--which, by reason of having once tried the experiment of printing on scented paper, was known in press circles as "The Stinker"--and subsequently became chief of the reporting staff of the _Comet_--as smart a staff as could be found in London.
In common with many other men in Fleet Street, that never-sleeping world of tape and flimsy, Dick had one failing--he had a penchant for a particular brand of whisky sold at the _Cheese_, the ancient house of steak-pudding fame, but he was always moderate, for his great pride was that his sub-editors could place the greatest reliance in him, as indeed they could. Dick Cleugh was certainly smart, even though his hair was often unkempt and a bundle of copy-paper usually poked out of the side-pocket of his well-worn overcoat. Over and over again had he proved himself a very brilliant pressman and had startled London by the "latest details" he had elicited where the police had failed.
I had arrived at our chambers about six, after a heavy day. I had visited Barking and Wandsworth, and had made an inquiry at Hammersmith, three districts far afield from one another, therefore I felt fagged and hungry. The Hag was engaged in fizzling the usual daily steak in the gas fumes, filling the place with a decidedly appetising odour; nevertheless, between Dick and I there was an arrangement that neither should eat without the other, unless a telegram arrived announcing a protracted absence. Therefore I lit a cigarette, cast myself into the trifle rickety but very comfortable armchair, and waited by the open window. I was just a trifle melancholy that evening, for there had come back to me recollections of a love-bond long since severed, of a face which was once very dear to me. But I was a lonely bachelor now. All was of the past. Soon, however, as I sat thinking, I saw Cleugh hurrying across the square, his silk hat, a trifle rusty, tilted at the back of his head, and a few moments later he burst merrily into the room, saying--
"Sorry to keep you so long, old chap, but we brought out an extra to-night. There's a bit of a row down in Parliament." Then, calling to Mrs. Joad, who was pottering in the "sink" beyond, he said, "Come along, mother. Look sharp with the horseflesh!"
The novel opens with a conversation on the Underground Railway, where the narrator, Frank Urwin, argues with his journalist friend Richard Cleugh about a mysterious occurrence. The setting—a train running into the “sulphurous ever-murky station of Blackfriars”—immediately establishes a London of grime and secrets. Le Queux uses the Underground as a recurring space for clandestine exchanges, mirroring the hidden connections Urwin insists exist between seemingly unrelated events.
Underground as a Stage for Secrets
The Underground Railway is not merely a setting but a structural device. The first chapter places Urwin and Cleugh in a train carriage, where they debate a secret “discovery.” Later, Cleugh reveals his broken engagement to Lily while “alone together in the train,” getting out at Elephant and Castle. These scenes use the confined, transient space of the carriage to force intimate revelations. The train’s movement through London’s “sulphurous” tunnels parallels the narrative’s progression through hidden layers of the city. Le Queux repeatedly returns to this motif, suggesting that the city’s transit system is a conduit for both physical travel and the exchange of dangerous knowledge.
The Journalist’s Voice and the Reporter’s Eye
Cleugh is described as “one of the sharpest men in Fleet Street,” a special reporter for the Comet. His profession is not incidental; it shapes the novel’s texture. He speaks in the language of Parliament, “moving that this House do now adjourn,” and his dialogue is peppered with journalistic cynicism. When Urwin protests his treatment of Lily, Cleugh deflects with a laugh and a drink, saying “Shut up, Frank, and be damned to you.” This voice—brusque, evasive, and self-justifying—creates a tension between what is said and what is withheld. The reader, like a reporter, must piece together clues from these verbal feints.
Hints of a Hidden Connection
Urwin insists that “the two affairs, mysterious as they are, are more closely connected than we imagine.” This claim, made in the opening pages, sets up a pattern of hinted linkages. Cleugh’s broken engagement to Lily, his past with Mary Blain, and his cryptic remark that Urwin will “agree with my course of action some day ere long” all point to a concealed web. Le Queux does not reveal the nature of this connection in the excerpts, but the narrative structure depends on such dangling threads. The reader is invited to suspect that every character and event is tethered to a central secret, though the evidence remains fragmentary.
Objects and Habits as Character Markers
Le Queux uses small, recurring details to define his characters. Cleugh’s pipe, bought for “fourpence halfpenny in Fleet Street nearly two years ago,” becomes a point of contention; Urwin offers to buy him a new one, but Cleugh refuses. The pipe’s cheapness and the smoke it produces—“a suffocating cloud”—mirror Cleugh’s stubbornness and the obscuring nature of his secrets. Similarly, his “cravat was habitually tied with carelessness,” and he wears a light overcoat except in August. These precise observations ground the characters in a tangible world, where habits and possessions carry meaning beyond their surface function.
Readers should attend to the spaces between dialogue—the pauses, the evasions, the moments when a character changes the subject. Le Queux builds his mystery not through dramatic action but through the accumulation of small, telling details. The novel rewards a careful eye for what is left unsaid, and for the recurring settings that frame each revelation.
There’s something touching about a mystery built on what people choose not to say—Le Queux’s London feels full of those silences. It reminded me of an old notebook I kept, half-finished thoughts about hidden stories, which is why I lingered over The Girl Who Had Nothing — Reading Notes. Same ache, different century, maybe. I just sat with that for a while.
There are no reviews for this eBook.
How did this book work for you?
Your answers remain private and are stored only in this browser.